Travis Annatoyn Speaks with Law360 on NEPA Reviews on Anniversary of Seven County Decision

Travis Annatoyn, Arnold & Porter counsel and former Deputy Solicitor for Energy and Mineral Resources at the U.S. Department of the Interior, was quoted in the Law360 article “Seven County’s Legacy Still Unwritten A Year Later,” which examines how the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Seven County Infrastructure Coalition v. Eagle County continues to affect federal environmental review and permitting practices under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA).

Travis discussed how the decision has increased confidence among agencies and project developers defending NEPA reviews against litigation challenges. He explained that while parties still strive to prepare “perfect and spotless” environmental review documents, Seven County has reduced concern that minor omissions or technical deficiencies will undermine otherwise robust agency analyses. Travis noted that the decision reinforces a more deferential judicial approach to agency decision-making and supports the idea that courts need not vacate project approvals over immaterial errors.

He also cautioned that Seven County does not insulate agencies from challenges based on substantive errors. He observed that aggressive permitting timelines and staffing constraints could increase the risk of agencies making significant analytical mistakes that remain vulnerable to judicial scrutiny. Accordingly, courts are still likely to intervene where agency decisions rely on flawed data or unreasonable analysis.

Read the full article (subscription required).