Jonathan Martel Unpacks Government Enforcement Discretion and Citizen Suits in Law360
Jonathan Martel, co-chair of Arnold & Porter’s Environmental practice group and a former attorney at the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) Office of General Counsel, was quoted in the recent Law360 article, “Citizen Suits Face Threat As Allegedly Unconstitutional Tactic,” discussing legal challenges to environmental citizen suits and the federal government’s argument that its enforcement discretion allows it to dismiss them.
Jonathan noted that under some circumstances the government has a legitimate reason to exercise that discretion, citing EPA’s practice of promising not to enforce certain laws during emergencies. “There were examples during Hurricane Katrina, when the supply of generators that were in compliance with Clean Air Act requirements were in short supply,” but others were available and needed, he said. “The agency issued a no-action assurance to say, ‘Go ahead and supply those violating engines, and we’re telling you in advance we are not going to pursue enforcement.’”
Jonathan also explained that even if a citizen suit were brought where the government had issued a no-action assurance, it would be in a court’s power to dismiss the case.
Read the full article (subscription required).